Sunday, August 16, 2009

Benegal on Ray on YouTube

Fans of Satyajit Ray, the film director, will thank a good samaritan, whose YouTube ID is kishor101982, for posting on that Web site, in its entirety, a valuable 1984 documentary on Ray's life and (mostly) work by Shyam Benegal, himself a giant of Indian cinema. To stay within YouTube's stringent 10-minute length limit, kishor101982 has chopped up Benegal's documentary into fourteen clips -- numbered from 0 to 13; we may have a computer programmer here! -- of reasonably high quality.

Luckily, I did not feel that I lost much in having to watch the film clip by clip with an interruption every nine-and-a-half minutes or so. Perhaps the documentary nature of the film had something to do with it; the annoyance factor would probably have been higher for a typical narrative feature film. In any case, one wonders what purpose is served by YouTube's ten-minute length limit if it is possible to get around it the way kishor101982 has. Sure, a ten-minute clip will load faster than a ninety-minute clip, but people who post to YouTube are aware of these trade-offs. So, why not let them make their own choices?

January 2026

Are You Aging Well? Try These Simple Tests to Find Out.  By Dana G. Smith, The New York Times, January 22, 2026 Syria, in Ruins   By Carlott...